Skin like it’s been kissed by the sun, that glow like after a holiday – you can have that without sunbathing. Stiftung Warentest tested 20 self-tanners. The test subjects creamed, sprayed or wiped the products on their legs for us, and we also sent the products to the laboratory. The result is impressive: the overall rating was good eleven times. An expensive luxury self-tanner is just ahead, closely followed by significantly cheaper products.
Why the self-tanner test is worth it for you
Testergebnisse
The self-tanning test provides quality ratings for 20 products. We tested classic branded products such as St. Tropez, St. Moriz, Rituals and Vichy, but also self-tanners from dm, Rossmann and Müller own brands. Also in the test: Two certified natural cosmetics.
The best self tanner for you
You can filter the tested products in the database, for example by test result, provider or price. Because the price differences are large: They are between 0.98 and 23.30 euros per 100 milliliters. The self-tanning wipes in the test cost between 0.35 and 1.50 euros each.
Expert advice
In an interview, a dermatologist and allergist provides information about the allergy risk of self-tanning products.
Magazine article as PDF
After activation, you will receive the magazine article from test 04/23 for download.
Test results for 20 self-tanners
Mousse to cloth: various self-tanners in the test
Lotions, gel-cream, milk, sprays, mousses – we have tested self-tanners in various forms of application, explain the advantages and disadvantages of the products and what is important when applying them. Also in the test: tinted products, which have the advantage that after application it is easy to see whether sufficient self-tanning agent has been distributed everywhere.
Tipp: Even before paying, you can see and filter all tested self-tanners in the database.
Formaldehyde: is tanning cream harmful?
In order for self-tanners to tint the skin, they must contain dihydroxyacetone, or DHA for short. This ingredient splits off formaldehyde. However, this is not indicated on the packaging of the products. We consider this to be problematic and demand that the providers should give the information – in the interest of people affected by a contact allergy to formaldehyde. The dermatologist and allergist Professor Axel Schnuch assesses the risk.
Application tips for self-tanners
- Self-tanner spreads more easily and evenly on smooth skin. Therefore, first exfoliate the skin thoroughly – especially on the knees, ankles, heels and elbows. If possible, shave hairy skin areas such as lower legs and shins.
- Wash hands thoroughly after application. Otherwise, the fingers and palms of the hands will also turn brown – it looks unnatural.
- Until the self-tanner has completely absorbed, avoid contact with clothing, towels, bed linen and light-colored furniture. It is best to use self-tanner in the evening and allow sufficient time for it to sink in.
- A tan produced by self-tanning products offers no protection against UV radiation. Therefore, use a sunscreen when sunbathing.