James W. Lewis, Suspect in Tylenol Murders, Dies at 76

83

Longtime Suspect in Tylenol Murders Dies at 76, Cause of Death Not Suspicious

October 1982 marked a time of fear and uncertainty for the residents of Chicago. Seven innocent individuals had tragically lost their lives after ingesting cyanide-laced Tylenol capsules. The chaos had catapulted the entire Chicago area into panic, with pharmacies hastily removing Tylenol from their shelves and authorities urging people to discard any of the product they had at home. The nation watched nervously, wondering if they too had unwittingly invited a murderer into their homes.

James W. Lewis, a suspect in the notorious “Tylenol murders” case, passed away at the age of 76, according to Cambridge Police Superintendent Fred Cabral. Lewis was found lifeless inside his Cambridge home on Sunday, after first responders received a call regarding an unresponsive person. Cabral assured The Washington Post that investigators had determined his death to be “not suspicious.”

The poisonings triggered a nationwide panic and forced Johnson & Johnson, the parent company of Tylenol, to recall millions of bottles of Tylenol capsules. This incident paved the way for significant changes in the sale of over-the-counter medicines, including the introduction of tamper-evident packaging and the rise of tablets as an alternative to capsules, as tablets cannot be disassembled.

The tragic events began unfolding before dawn on September 29, 1982. Mary Kellerman, a 12-year-old girl, complained of a cold and requested to stay home from school. To alleviate her symptoms, she took an extra-strength Tylenol capsule in the bathroom. Her father heard her cough and a sound of something falling to the floor, only to find his daughter lying lifeless when she opened the bathroom door. She tragically passed away a few hours later.

Mary and six other individuals from the Chicago area lost their lives over the course of three days. Authorities scrambled to determine the source of the mysterious deaths and promptly removed Tylenol bottles from store shelves and homes.

Amidst the nationwide panic, Johnson & Johnson received a letter demanding $1 million to “stop the killing.” The letter ominously mentioned the ease with which cyanide could be inserted into capsules found on store shelves. It stated, “If you don’t mind the advertising for these little capsules, don’t do nothing…” Eventually, it was discovered that James W. Lewis had penned the letter. Although never charged with the murders, Lewis was convicted of attempting to extort Johnson & Johnson and served more than 12 years in prison.

Lewis, who had been a long-time suspect in the case for over 40 years, shared a detailed account of how the murders had been committed when arrested by FBI agents in a New York library in December 1982. However, in a 1992 interview with the Associated Press, Lewis clarified that he was not confessing but rather providing possible scenarios for the killer’s actions. Described as a “chameleon” by law enforcement, Lewis had held various jobs, including one in pharmaceutical machinery, and had used at least 20 different aliases.

Investigators discovered that Lewis was motivated by a desire to embarrass his wife’s former employer, from whom she had been terminated. He wrote the extortion letter on company stationery and forged his wife’s former boss’s signature. Police officers deemed the attempt clumsy, noting that it would have been nearly impossible for Lewis to collect the demanded $1 million from his wife’s former employer’s business account.

In 2009, Illinois authorities reopened the investigation, leading to the seizure of a computer and other belongings from Lewis’s home by the FBI, according to the Associated Press. Last year, Illinois state police and local law enforcement attempted to convince state prosecutors to file murder charges against Lewis. While lacking physical evidence connecting him to the crimes, they claimed to possess an “indictable circumstantial case,” the Chicago Tribune reported.

The Tylenol murders still haunt the memory of the nation. With the passing of James W. Lewis, many questions remain unanswered, leaving some to speculate about the true identity of the heinous, cold-blooded murderer behind these horrific crimes.

(C) The Washington Post.