The US Supreme Court debated whether it is legal to fine homeless people for sleeping on the street

45

Activists Rally Outside Supreme Court as Justices Consider Appeal on Homeless Sleeping Ban

WASHINGTON, DC – As the U.S. Supreme Court deliberates on a crucial appeal regarding the ban on homeless people sleeping on the streets, activists gathered in front of the courthouse to advocate for more affordable housing and urge the justices to consider the pressing issue of homelessness in America.

The case originated in Grants Pass, Oregon, where fines were imposed on individuals who were found sleeping outdoors as housing costs soared and shelters reached full capacity. The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals deemed the law unconstitutional, citing that penalizing individuals for camping without adequate shelter alternatives constitutes cruel and unusual punishment.

During oral arguments, the justices grappled with the complexity of the homelessness crisis, with Justice Sonia Sotomayor emphasizing the basic human need for sleep and questioning where individuals are supposed to rest if cities lack compassion and viable housing options. Justice Brett Kavanaugh acknowledged the challenging nature of the problem, highlighting the dilemma of imposing fines in the absence of sufficient shelter accommodations.

Outside the Supreme Court, hundreds of demonstrators voiced their support for homeless rights, demanding “housing, not handcuffs” and showcasing silver thermal blankets symbolizing the harsh realities faced by those living on the streets. The protesters underscored the urgency of the situation, as homelessness rates continue to rise nationwide, with over 650,000 individuals lacking permanent housing.

The ruling in this case could have far-reaching implications for how cities address homelessness, particularly in the Western states where the issue is most prevalent. While concerns were raised about public health and safety in homeless encampments, activists argued that punitive measures only exacerbate the crisis and hinder efforts to provide long-term solutions.

As the Supreme Court deliberates on this critical matter, the outcome could significantly impact the lives of countless homeless individuals across the country. With a decision expected by the end of June, the case represents a defining moment in the ongoing struggle to address homelessness and housing insecurity in America.

(With information from AP)